Development approvals: when is it worth pushing?
Updated: 14 hours ago
When a client comes to us with a site under the traditional character overlay, the first question I ask is “What’s your appetite for risk?” Two of our projects show why.
Apex in Paddington sits under that overlay. Before we were involved, the previous owner spent two years pushing a very modern design through council, only to be told no. When our clients took the site on, they knew that history and chose to design as close to compliant as possible. Apex was approved quickly and has since won regional and state awards.
Windward in Manly is a different story. It’s a small lot under the same overlay. The house is three storeys and quite contemporary from the street. The site sat at the edge of the traditional character area, there were contemporary homes across the road, and the upper level had views towards Moreton Bay.
Before giving our clients final advice, I took the drawings to our town planner and asked whether he could back them through the DA process. He agreed he could. So we told our clients we could really push here, but council might ask questions or request changes. They said yes, let’s give it our best shot. Council approved the design, and Windward and its sister house are now under construction.
If you take that approach, council might ask you to explain why the design works on that street. You might need to make a few tweaks, or you could find yourself redesigning a façade. And just because the house up the road got approved doesn’t mean yours will. Every site is assessed on its own.
Knowing when to push comes from many years of looking at sites, getting the right team involved and having clients who understand the risk and are comfortable taking it. So before you start designing, ask yourself, “What’s my appetite for risk?” Then get advice from someone who has real experience with DAs. That could be us, or a good town planner.
Got a site with an overlay? Tell us what you want, and we’ll tell you honestly what it’ll take.


Comments